How do polygraphs detect lies
They know they can get away with it, and if they know it, they are more likely to be able to do so. When a suspect does not confess, some polygraph operators will browbeat the suspect, telling the suspect that the machine has shown that the suspect is not telling the truth. By increasing detection apprehension, the hope is to make the guilty confess. The innocent suffer the false accusations but supposedly will be vindicated.
Unfortunately, under such pressures some innocents will confess in order to obtain relief. Anyone can learn how to spot deception. There are several things to consider regarding polygraphs and Voice Stress Analyzations: They are good at detecting stress! Many things can cause stress. For example, if the examiner asks the subjects about theft, the subject may be innocent of the theft, but may be reminded of an incident in which they know someone who committed a theft, and can show stress in their answer.
An astute examiner has to take such things into account when formulating the questions. In fact, the results of the polygraph are so often really inconclusive that the results of a polygraph test are inadmissible in court.
They encourage people to confess. Forensic psychologist Theresa Gannon and her colleagues studied this on UK sex offenders in This disclosure often happened after the polygraph had indicated deception.
It may be that offenders feel forced to make a confession after failing the polygraph. However, the study could not tell whether these confessions are true. This research suggests that the polygraph can be used to psychologically pressure offenders into disclosing self-incriminating information. Information that may not even be true. So, is it a good idea for the government to increase polygraph use to monitor offenders? Research shows that they are nowhere near foolproof, but they may have some usefulness as a potential indicator of deception and to encourage truth telling.
However, using them raises several ethical questions. In short, polygraph tests record a number of different bodily responses which can then be used to determine whether someone is telling the truth.
They usually measure things like blood pressure, changes in a person's breathing, and sweating on the palms. So polygraph tests do not measure deception or lying directly, but rather possible signs that a person could be deceiving the interviewer.
This information is then used in conjunction with everything else that is known about the person to form a clearer picture of whether or not they are being truthful. Polygraphs have been used around the world, in countries such as Japan, Russia and China, but the technology remains largely the same.
This is followed by a practice test, which usually involves a number of straightforward questions. The aim is to relax the individual so they are comfortable and able to understand how the process works.
The equipment is then attached, and it usually includes a blood pressure monitor, electrodes which are placed on the fingers or palm, and two tubes which are wrapped around the chest and stomach. Interviewers ask a number of control questions during the test and then compare the responses to the key questions.
It finishes with a post-test interview, where the person will be able to explain any responses they showed.
He says that it requires sitting down and practising with a trained examiner. But for those who don't have a qualified questioner to hand - what methods can work? However, knowing how the machines work, you can beat them by lying with your body as well as your words.
When you're taking a polygraph test, the machine first registers the baseline of your vital signs. Examiners then trick you into lying by asking you a series of "control" questions that are only distantly related to the issue they're investigating, such as "Did you ever lie to get out of trouble? As soon as the examinee tells such a white lie, it puts a blip on the polygraph machine that serves as a signature of that examinee's lies.
Mixed in with the control questions are relevant questions. In a drug case, for example, a polygrapher will ask, "Did you ever use an illegal drug? If the former reactions are greater, the examinee passes; if the latter are greater, he fails.
0コメント