Why is tarnish a chemical change

Explanation: Chemical change is characterized by the formation of new substances, and the making and breaking of chemical bonds.

Related questions How can you increase the speed of a chemical change? What is a chemical change? How are physical changes different from chemical changes? Do chemical changes involve energy? Rusting and tarnishing are two chemical changes that matter undergoes. Failure to rust or tarnish is evidence that there was no chemical change with respect to a reaction with oxygen, or other oxidant.

But that evidence isn't enough to flatly state whether a chemical or physical change occurs, as is suggested by the question. The questions seems to infer a change occurred, but it wasn't due to rust or tarnish.

I found that when using this process, trying to re-use the solution more than twice really slowed the reaction down. Since baking soda is cheap, I just make up a new batch of water and baking soda every two or three treatments. You will also notice that the silver will dry with a bit of a white residue on it. That is just residual baking soda — a quick rinse in clean water and a dry with a towel will make that disappear, leaving you with nice bright silver.

As previously mentioned, this tarnish-removal method uses a chemical reaction to convert the silver sulfide back into silver. Many metals in addition to silver form compounds with sulfur. Some of them have a greater affinity for sulfur than silver does. Aluminum is one of them — and luckily, most people already have lots of it in a convenient to use form in their kitchens.

In this case, the silver sulfide reacts with aluminum. In the reaction, sulfur atoms are transferred from the silver to the aluminum, freeing the silver metal and forming aluminum sulfide.

Chemists represent this reaction with a chemical equation. The reaction between silver sulfide and aluminum takes place when the two are in contact while they are immersed in a baking soda solution.

As with almost all chemical reactions, the reaction is faster when the solution is warm. The solution carries the sulfur from the silver to the aluminum.

The aluminum sulfide may adhere to the aluminum foil, it may be found floating in the water having detached from the foil or it may form tiny, pale yellow flakes in the bottom of the pan.

The silver and aluminum must be in contact with each other, because a small electric current flows between them during the reaction. This type of reaction, which involves an electric current, is called an electrochemical reaction. Reactions of this type are used in batteries to produce electricity. Hopefully, this little bit of science will make your future holiday preparations faster and easier — not to mention saving your silver to be enjoyed for many years to come. This entry was posted on Saturday, January 18th, at pm and is filed under Chemistry , High School level , Middle School level.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2. You can leave a response , or trackback from your own site. Are these statements correct? Thanks for asking.

We sent this question out to Ron Perkins, the founder of EI and retired Chemistry of over 30 years and this is his answer. Most of the methods published use aluminum and hot water containing baking soda in order to make a slightly basic solution. A few recipes suggest substituting baking soda with washing soda which would give a stronger basic solution and cause the reaction to occur faster, but this substitution is definitely not recommended for valuable silver pieces.

Although this electrochemical process will indeed remove the tarnish and make the silver appear shiny again, the process should not be used on valuable silver pieces such as coins, antique silver, or sterling. The problem is that the process returns the silver from the tarnish to the surface of the metal object but probably, not where the silver atoms were originally.

Under a microscope, the originally smooth silver surface can be seen becoming more pitted and rougher each time the tarnish removal process is used.

Loved this article. Thank you so much for posting it — I love having the explanation as well as the technique. Do you know? In order to find the answer to your question, we reached out to Ron Perkins, the founder of Educational Innovations and Chemistry teacher for over 30 years.

This is what he said:. If the tarnish is a sulfide of copper, the same method may work to obtain pure copper. Sounds like a good experiment for some student to try. Sooooo, having a little trouble with an unclear antecedent. I have used washing soda for tarnish removal decades ago, but was not happy with the result, probably for the reason you give. The texture was never as silky and lovely ever again. I now deal in fine antique silver and just yesterday could feel the temptation to start boiling when a particularly intricate teapot was giving me fits.

I suspect you meant either medium would be damaging. One rule: never clean antique coins!!!! It says that the aluminum must make cpontact with the silver for the electro-whatever to take place. Will it work if siverware is piled loosely in the container? I get that with using more pieces the process might be less effective. I used the baking soda solution and aluminum to clean some sterling silver that had been sitting in the back of a cupboard for decades and was totally black.

I put it on low heat on my stove to keep it warm. Left it too long, and now there is a rough whitish coating on some of the pieces. What is this and can I do anything about it?

The tarnish basically forms a protective, yet, ugly layer on the silver metal. Thank you so much for your cool post. We homeschool and I love thrifting, so for an outing we specifically searched for silver items at the Goodwill in our neighborhood.

We found some amazing candle sticks and your pots totally cleaned them, restored brilliantly! Would the reaction be expedited by insulating the silver target from the aluminum and applying a voltage between the two?

In electrochemical reactions, one always needs a complete circuit, otherwise nothing happens. If the Ag is insulated from the Al it is not a complete circuit.

This would be like attaching an Al wire to the positive terminal and a silver wire to the negative terminal of a battery and not letting the wires touch. There can be no flow of electrons. Electrochemistry is fun to think about and relatively safe to see what happens if you use only a single flashlight battery, a D or C cell.

It works!. Rapid evolution of H2S where previously was getting nowhere with just hot solution. Current starts to flow at about 2. Silver cleans up nicely but needed a minor final once over with silver cleaner. Thanks for sharing your experiments! Reading through it I saw that the reaction is partially incorrect. The product of the reaction is aluminium oxide, Al2O3 and not aluminium sulfide, Al2S3.

The latter is actually unstable in aqueous medium, decomposing to Al2O3. Thanks so much, Priscilla! Physical change. The actual tarnishing action is a chemical change, as a new compound silver oxide is formed.

Tarnish on silver is Silver Oxide, which is oxidised silver. This is indeed a chemical reaction. It's a chemical change because a new substance comes out of tarnishing. It is a chemical change because when copper tarnishes, it combines with oxygen to become a new substance. You can also tell because of the change of color, a sign of chemical change. The tarnishing of silver is due to a reaction with hydrogen sulfide.

Because the end result of the tarnish is silver sulfide, it is a chemical change. Which of the following is an example of a physical rather then a chemical change? Log in. Study now. See Answer. Best Answer. Tarnish is an example of chemical change because the oxygen in the air is combining with gold or silver, or whatever the object is made of and makes the tarnish. Study guides. Chemistry 20 cards. How does a buffer work. What happens in a neutralization reaction.

What is a conjugate acid-base pair. Why is water considered to be neutral. Physics 20 cards.